Background: Â Several congenital malformations such as craniofacial and digitalÂ abnormalities, and less commonly, cleft lip and palate have been reported withÂ phenobarbital. According to our knowledge, it is the first report of cloacal anomalyÂ and cleft palate following prenatal phenobarbital exposure.
Case: A 20-year-old gravid 1, Para 1 woman at 40 weeks of gestation was admittedÂ for a normal vaginal delivery. She had a history of convulsion one month beforeÂ pregnancy. The described dosage of Phenobarbital by her physician was 100mgÂ every night but she had increased the dosage to 100mg q8h incidentally. OtherÂ medication was folic acid in usual dosage and continued until delivery. There wasÂ no familial history of birth defects, any antenatal infection or exposure to any otherÂ medications, alcohol, smoking, or exposure to X-rays. Pregnancy was uncomplicatedÂ and a baby girl weighing 2600g was born. APGAR scores were 8 and 9 at 1 andÂ 5 minutes, respectively. By clinical picture, diagnosis of cloacal anomaly wasÂ confirmed. The other anomalies were cleft palate, a small patent ductus arteriosusÂ in echocardiography and a short sacrum. A nuclear renal scan, which was performedafter two months, suggested severe decrease perfusion and function of right kidney.Â The patient was treated with multiple operations on oral, urogenital and anorectalÂ system.Â
Conclusion: In addition to previously recognized risks associated withÂ phenobarbital during pregnancy, cloacal anomaly should be considered as a possibleÂ adverse outcome.
Phenobarbital is the oldest antiepileptic drug (AED) currently in use. Several congenital malformation such as craniofacial and digital abnormalities, and less commonly, cleft lip and palate have been reported with AEDs including Phenobarbital [1,2,3]. In this report, we present a patient who received Phenobarbital more than the recommended dose and her offspring was born with two major malformations including cloacal anomaly and cleft palate. As well as we know, this is the first report of cloacal anomaly with Phenobarbital.
A 20-year-old gravid 1, Para 1 woman at 40 weeks of gestation was admitted for a normal vaginal delivery. She had a history of convulsion one month before pregnancy for which she was treated with Phenobarbital 100mg q8h in the first trimester of pregnancy. The described dosage of Phenobarbital by her physician was 100mg every night but she had increased the dosage to 100mg q8h incidentally. Other medication was folic acid in usual dosage and continued until delivery. The father was 25-years old and there was no consanguinity. There was no familial history of birth defects, any antenatal infection or exposure to any other medications, alcohol, smoking, or exposure to X-rays. The result of prenatal ultrasound was moderate polyhydramnius and a baby weighing 2600g was born. The karyotype of the offspring was female. APGAR scores were 8 and 9 at 1 and 5 minutes, respectively. By clinical picture diagnosis of cloacal anomaly (figure 1) was confirmed. (Table 1).
The other anomalies were cleft palate (hard and soft) and a small patent ductus arteriosus in echocardiography. X-ray (figure 2) showed obviously a short sacrum.
A voiding cystouretrography showed right vesicoureteral reflux (grade four). A nuclear renal scan, which was performed after two months, suggested severe decrease perfusion and function of right kidney. The patient was treated with multiple operations on oral, urogenital and anorectal system.
It has long been recognized that AEDs increase the risk of malformation in fetus. The most common major malformations associated with AED exposure include cardiac (e.g., ventricular septal defect), orofacial (e.g., cleft lip with or without cleft palate), urological (e.g., hypospadias), skeletal (e.g., radial ray defects, phalangeal hypoplasia), and neural tube defects (NTDs) . Congenital malformations including cleft lip and palate are not new adverse pregnancy outcomes with phenobarbital as they have been reported in the several reports and registries [3,4,5,6].
In the North American Registry , phenobarbital was associated with 6.5% of major congenital abnormalities with a relative risk (RR) of 2 versus other AEDs. Similar findings was reported by Tanaka et al  as phenobarbital use was associated with retarded fetal growth and 6.7% of congenital malformation that was higher than carbamazepine (0%) and lower than valproate (10.3%). In contrast, in some surveys, there was not any congenital abnormality with phenobarbital. Endo et al  conducted a survey including 36 deliveries of 25 mothers with epilepsy. They founded that there was not any congenital abnormality with phenobarbital and the cleft lip with palate was happened in just one case received other agent.
In a recent meta-analysis conducted by Meador et al , it has been calculated that phenobarbital is associated with a 4.91% risk of malformation. The risk of other AEDs including Valproate, Phenytoin, Carbamazepine and Lamotrigine were 10.73%, 7.36%, 4.62% and 2.91% respectively.
As well as we know, coloac anomaly has not been reported with phenobarbital use during pregnancy. It is the most complex type of imperforate anus with confluence of the rectum, vagina, and bladder in a urogenital sinus, with a relatively poor functional outcome of the bowel, the genital tract and the urinary tract. Although comprehensive surgical planning may help the children to achieve a reasonable lifestyle .
Since the patient received just phenobarbital and folic acid, the most probable cause of this anomaly is phenobarbital. Based on the current recommendations, folic acid is not only safe, but also could prevent the NTDs occurring in general population and in women at high risk due to NTDs in previous pregnancies . In addition to anatomical teratogenesis, phenobarbital exposure was associated with cognitive deficits including reduced IQ [11,12].
It is notable that we can not conclusively link the cloacal anomaly to the phenobarbital, as this anomaly may occur in approximately 1 of 50,000 births. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) classification systems proposed for causality assessment (including certain, probable, possible, unlikely, conditional/unclassified and unassessable/ unclassifiable), this adverse reaction of phenobarbital can be classified as a possible side effect .
Base on the current evidences, valporate poses the greatest risk to the fetus among AEDs followed by phenytoin and phenobarbital. The overall risks for carbamazepine and lamotrigine appear to be relatively low .
Various mechanisms have been proposed for the teratogenicity of AEDs, including folate-related defects, ischemia, neuronal suppression, free radicals and AED-induces neuronal apoptosis . It has been demonstrated that phenobarbital, like as phenytoin, vigabatrin, and valproate, induces widespread neuronal apoptosis in immature animal brains [14,15]. In addition, interaction if AEDs with susceptible genotypes has been suggested and may explain different susceptibilities of individuals .
Another important issue of the presented case is the medication error. As noted, the patient received erratically phenobarbital 300 mg/day instead of the scheduled 100 mg/day dosage. Since the malformation induced by phenobarbital is possibly a dose-dependent phenomenon after 60 mg/day [1,17], using the lowest effective dose is a critical point. It is notable that the Phenobarbital level was not checked during pregnancy. It has been recommended that the blood levels of AEDs including Phenobarbital should be monitored during pregnancy to avoid toxicity, although increase clearance and low levels are a more common complication .
In addition to previously recognized risks associated with phenobarbital during pregnancy, cloacal anomaly should be considered as a possible adverse outcome. The case presented might be due to phenobarbital effect or other causes remain further investigation of the problem in a larger and more representative birth population than that described. According to the current evidences, the safer AEDs with the lowest effective dosage (e.g., carbamazepine and lamotrigine) should be used for epileptic patients instead of more toxic agents such as valproate and phenobarbital. Also we recommend closed observation regarding ultrasound and fetal echocardiography for any pregnant woman on anticonvulsant therapy.
All Published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved. iMedPub LTD Last revised : September 14, 2019